Straight Platform Politics

Health Care Reform And Veterans – Part 1

Recent health care reform proposals have caused the public to evaluate the health care systems currently operated by the U.S. government, namely the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) and the Indian Health Service. The quality of these government-run systems is not encouraging.

Some people continue to refer to past studies that found the VHA to be better than Medicare, managed-care systems, and the highest rated non-VHA hospitals. Phillip Longman, in his article “The Best Care Anywhere,” (Washington Monthly Jan/Feb 2005) observed: “Outside experts agree that the VHA has become an industry leader in its safety and quality measures.”

But that was then.

Earlier this year, more than 10,000 former VHA patients were notified that they could have been exposed to HIV or hepatitis B or C through unsafe endoscopic procedures. These procedures involved substandard, unclean practices; some of these procedures were done as long ago as 2003. Three different states were involved – Florida, Tennessee, and Georgia. Unfortunately, 53 patients have tested positive so far.

U.S. Rep. Harry Mitchell, chair of the House Veterans’ Affairs Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, had this to say in a June press release: “Most infuriating is the irony that these veterans were undergoing routine medical evaluations to prevent illness, but ultimately, they may be in more danger now than before the procedures. [T]here is no question that shoddy standards – systemic across the VA – put veterans at risk and dealt a blow to their trust in the VA.”

And a blow to our trust in the ability of government to provide descent health care to many more people than just veterans.  See Health Care Reform And The Bridge

HIV mode of transmission, HIV testing, Indian Health Service, Phillip Longman, U.S. Rep. Harry Mitchell, U.S. government, VA, Veterans Health Administration, health care reform, health care system, hepatitis